'There Is No Doctor!" Day 4 - LyLo, Obvs

[The Goocher]

That's interesting. I assume we have a doctor to protect LK. I wouldn't imagine giving the town so many cop roles yet still giving scum a strong arm to get through it. 

[Kris]

With as many players as we have, I think it breaks down like this:

2 Mafia
1 Innocent child
4 Cops, all variants represented (of which 3 are left)

Your theory of there being a doctor makes sense, so we'll throw one of those in there as well... leaving one role unaccounted for. Any thoughts?

[red]

Oh shit... I totally mind blanked when I typed my last post. (I was in class, and getting mind mobbed during a review) I AM a cop. So my freak out was dumb as shit. xp Though, I seem to have forgot to send in my night action. I thought I did. O-o

[red]

EBWOP: Apparently I didn't even post that message. Fuckin hell. Do not mafia and school at the same time folks. xp

[Madman]

I'm also a town cop... I didn't inquire about myself. (I didn't even think that was possible) So we know TLK is a townie added to a few cops. I think it was interesting APB made a last minute push to have someone lynched...perhaps he's scum. Also BD and Mania have been awfully quiet throughout so far, just a couple of lines here and there, maybe trying not to put any attention on themselves.

[red]

Well, evidence suggests (assuming we had four cops to start) that one of the four of us who has claimed cop is in fact scum(at the very least). There are only three remaining. I'm going to guess Goocher is clean. He claimed this shit first before people started to pile on. So I'm looking at Madison and Kris now.

Madison has been the first to start tossing blame. Lot's of smoke about people being quiet. That always smells to me. Even point at APB for pushing for a day 1 lynch. Day 1 lynching happens all the time, and all kinds of people see them as valuable. I have a hard time using that as a reason to point to scum.

On another point, Kris, your player breakdown is missing someone, we currently stand at 8 living, not 6. There is apparently stuff we haven't heard from yet. Possible third party maybe?

[Madman]

Well Red, I know your town, I had early suspicions about you so I used my night abilities as town cop on you which came back Not Guilty. So with certainty I can say I'm not lynching you or TLK. As for throwing names around...I was merely just trying to get some conversation started. Early lynches benefit the mafia. While we sit here, bicker back and forth and eat our own they need less and less votes to get us lynched...

[Kris]

Dec 3, 2013 19:13:37 GMT -5 red said:

On another point, Kris, your player breakdown is missing someone, we currently stand at 8 living, not 6. There is apparently stuff we haven't heard from yet. Possible third party maybe?

You're right, it is. That means there's two people that are without roles instead of one-- either that or a potential doubling up on the types of cop. There are only four of those, right?

1) Standard
2) Naive - Everyone is innocent.
3) Paranoid - Everyone is guilty.
4) I don't know what it's called, but it's the one where the innocence and guilt of people are switched.

Now here's the rub; we don't know what kind of cop Raab was.

Gooch and I both need to use our night actions on others to figure out what kind of cops we are. Madison needs to check himself to see what kind of cop he is since it's possible he's that type #4 up there. That leaves us with Red, which honestly?

F.o.S.: Red

With a combination of how Madison didn't know what kind of cop he was and how you 'apparently forgot' to send in a night action? I find that a little bit fishy. Not fishy enough to throw down a vote, but it's definitely something we should be considering.

[red]

Hey, I know it sounds fishy. But at the same time, shit happens. I have very busy days, and more often then not I'll peak at Maf while I'm at school. I even typed out a response to this thread a lot closer to the beginning of day 2 and just didn't hit send. Accidents happen.

That being said, I'm in an interesting position. We have a bullshit amount of cops hanging about, with the most likely number being four (3 once we consider the dead vanilla cop). Four claims, and two of the have alleged to have already checked themselves out. Madison apparently checked me with the possibility of being the loopy ass cop.

It almost feels like my best proof would be to tell people to lynch me. But at the same time that seems dumb as fuck, so we aren't going there, even if I look fishy as all hell at the moment. I'm still sitting on a big ass question Mark. One of the "cops" has to be scum.

[Madman]

Dec 3, 2013 21:39:47 GMT -5 red said:

Four claims, and two of the have alleged to have already checked themselves out. Madison apparently checked me with the possibility of being the loopy ass cop.

Yeah we can chalk that up to my inexperience in this game. I didn't even know that was a possibility. I'm definitely going to check myself on Night two, if I make it... The question is do we have enough for a lynch?

["The Last King"]

Well there are 8 players left right? 8 players = 5 to lynch.

Assuming Red and Chris are town, throw in the Gooch and me that's 4. Then again, who can really be certain that Gooch and Red are town? I'm willing to bet Gooch is standard, but Naive and Insane are still a possibility. Hmmmm...

FoS:Red

[The Goocher]

Come on guys. FOSing does nothing.

If we're going to climb the tower, let's ring the bell. 

If we think someone is guilty, let's throw a vote down. It's not like we don't have enough cops to go around. 

[red]

Fair enough then.

Vote: Kris

Clearly it has got to be one of the cops. Madison has cleared me as innocent. I can obviously attest to that as being true, so I'm not going to vote for him now. And Gooch was the first person to jump on saying that he was cop. Kris came on after someone else revealed their role. Taking everything I can in to account, this lynch makes the most sense to me.

[Maverick]

I will send out some prods, but for the most part I leave it up to you guys to police your own game.

[blackdeath]

interesting , both of you